PROBATIVE OPPOSABILITY Jean-François ELSEN PROBATIVE OPPOSABILITY Jean-François ELSEN

SOURCE 0 - THE DETERMINATION THAT CHANGED SYSTEMS MID-CASE

Well over one hundred federal claims against Roblox are centralized in MDL No. 3166. The age-determination mechanism the claims depend on was not the same throughout the conduct period. Discovery can compel records — it cannot retroactively convert them into the independent, contemporaneous fixation they were never built to contain.

Lire la suite
PROBATIVE OPPOSABILITY Jean-François ELSEN PROBATIVE OPPOSABILITY Jean-François ELSEN

SOURCE 0 - AGE QUALIFICATION WITHOUT A CERTAIN DATE

An age-prediction system and a biometric age-verification service produce the same effect on a user account through entirely different processing. Public documentation does not establish, for either, when a compliance assessment was produced relative to deployment — nor whether an individual determination is preserved in a form a third party could later verify. This case study examines the gap under the AI Act and the GDPR, and what an independent, pre-execution seal can and cannot establish about it.

Lire la suite
PROBATIVE OPPOSABILITY Jean-François ELSEN PROBATIVE OPPOSABILITY Jean-François ELSEN

SOURCE 0 - QUALIFICATION SEAL

Any organization that determines, through an automated system, an individual's status produces a qualification whose evidentiary trace it alone retains. SOURCE 0 QUALIFICATION SEAL fixes a determined representation of that qualification, at a timestamped instant, independently of the system that produced it — without ruling on its accuracy, effective application, or lawfulness. First documented use case: age determination.

Lire la suite
AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN

SOURCE 0 - THE SEARCH THAT WAS ALREADY BUILT

A coalition of news publishers has asked a federal court to sanction OpenAI, alleging the company concealed for two years that it had already built the capability to search its training data and ChatGPT logs, and that it continued deleting logs after being ordered to preserve them. This note examines what the allegation illustrates about verifying a preserving party's own compliance, independently of whether the allegation is proven.

Lire la suite
AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN

SOURCE 0 - THE RECORD THIS DISCOVERY ORDER DID NOT CREATE

A federal court has ordered UnitedHealth to hand over two years of records on nH Predict, the AI tool at the center of a Medicare Advantage coverage-denial lawsuit — while explicitly declining to decide, at this stage, whether the tool made the decisions plaintiffs allege it made. This note examines what a discovery order of this breadth can and cannot establish, and why the same structural gap runs through comparable disputes involving other insurers.

Lire la suite
AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN

SOURCE 0 - THE SAME TOOL, THE OTHER SIDE

A tool already cited as a textbook case of a flawed evidentiary architecture is, weeks later, named by a government as one of the instruments of a cyberattack against its own agencies. This note carefully distinguishes what Taiwan has confirmed from what the private research that surfaced the case advances separately, then examines what this reversal of roles changes — and above all does not change — for the party subjected to the attack.

Lire la suite
AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN

SOURCE 0 - LE MÊME OUTIL, L'AUTRE CÔTÉ

Un outil déjà cité comme cas d'école d'une architecture probatoire défaillante se retrouve, quelques semaines plus tard, nommé par un gouvernement comme l'un des instruments d'une cyberattaque contre ses propres agences. Cette note distingue soigneusement ce que Taïwan a confirmé de ce que la recherche privée qui a révélé l'affaire avance séparément, puis examine ce que ce renversement de rôle change — et surtout ne change pas — pour la partie qui subit l'attaque.

Lire la suite
AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN

SOURCE 0 - AUTONOMOUS AGENTS AND THE EVIDENTIARY VOID

An autonomous agent's logs are not proof of what it did — they are an allegation made by the same system whose integrity is in question. This article examines a documented incident record to show why a security patch cannot retroactively establish prior agent state, and introduces SOURCE 0 WITNESS, the declination of the SOURCE 0 architecture that seals agent state at an independently isolated point of observation before that trust can be contested.

Lire la suite
AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN AUTONOMOUS AI GOVERNANCE Jean-François ELSEN

SOURCE 0 - LES AGENTS AUTONOMES ET LE VIDE PROBATOIRE

Les journaux d'un agent autonome ne sont pas la preuve de ce qu'il a fait — ce sont une allégation produite par le système même dont l'intégrité est en cause. Cet article examine un historique d'incidents documenté pour montrer pourquoi un correctif de sécurité ne peut pas établir rétroactivement l'état antérieur d'un agent, et présente SOURCE 0 WITNESS, la déclinaison de l'architecture SOURCE 0 qui scelle l'état de l'agent depuis un point d'observation isolé, avant que cette confiance ne puisse être contestée.

Lire la suite